Free shipping over fifty dollars is quietly eating the margin I thought I had

Aisha Wright· DTC skincare brand for melanin-rich skin; first 300 units shipped· Open, E-Commerce & DTC·4d

I set the free shipping threshold at fifty dollars because every store I admire has one and mine felt naked without it. Four months later I sat down with the actual orders on a Sunday and most of them land between fifty-two and fifty-six dollars. People are adding the cheapest thing in the cart to clear the bar, which means I'm shipping heavier boxes to hit a threshold that was supposed to raise my order value.

Two other things I didn't plan for:

a serum bottle arrived leaking last week, so I refunded and reshipped and that order cost me twice
I'm packing everything myself in the spare room, about nine hours a week I don't have

I got a quote from a fulfillment warehouse and the per-order number looked fine until I added storage and the receiving fee, at which point it looked like a bet on volume I don't have yet.

Has anyone raised their threshold after the fact and survived it? And for those of you who moved to a third party, what was the actual trigger, the order count or the hours?

3 replies

Maya Fischer· Named it·3d

Breakage is my entire life so on that part at least I can be useful. I double box everything now. Mug in a fitted box, box in a bigger box, two inches of paper on every side. It added about a dollar and change per order and my replacement rate went to almost nothing. Cheaper than the refund and much cheaper than the message where someone photographs a broken handle.

On the threshold, I raised mine in February and told nobody. Not one person mentioned it. I think we believe customers are watching us far more closely than they actually are.

Aisha Wright· Open·3d

'I raised mine and told nobody' is going straight into my notes. I have been drafting an apologetic email in my head for a week about a change nobody has asked me to explain.

Double boxing is the move on the serum too. My filler is one sad sheet of bubble wrap because I was optimising for the unboxing video and not for the fact that a truck exists between me and the customer.

Greg Foster· Open·2d

Different corner of retail, I have a storefront and ship the overflow, so take it for what it is. The thing that finally stopped me packing at night wasn't the order count, it was that I was doing it badly by the end of the week and the mistakes cost more than the labour. Wrong size, wrong address, a jacket that went out unpressed.

Before you commit to a warehouse, look at whether you can pay a person for two mornings a week. That's what I did for a year and it bought back the hours without signing up for storage fees on inventory that isn't moving yet.

Sign in to reply

Replying and upvoting need a free LaunchAdvisor account. Reading is open to everyone.