Amazon vs Etsy vs Shopify vs Your Own Site: Where to Sell First
Product businesses face a decision before they sell a single unit: where do customers actually buy? Each platform comes with a different audience, fee structure, and long-term strategy. Getting this wrong means building on someone else's land with someone else's rules.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The quick answer
Start on Etsy if you make handmade, vintage, or craft goods and want built-in traffic from day one. Start on Amazon if you have a mass-market product with clear search demand. Start on Shopify if you are building a brand and want to own your customer relationships. Use your own simple website for service businesses — skip the marketplaces entirely.
Side-by-side breakdown
Amazon: 300+ million active buyers. Fees range from 8-15% referral fee plus FBA fulfillment fees if you use their warehouses. The advantage is existing demand — customers are already searching for what you sell. The disadvantage is brutal competition, no customer relationship (Amazon owns the buyer), and constant price pressure.
Etsy: 90+ million active buyers for handmade and vintage goods. Listing fee is $0.20 per item plus 6.5% transaction fee. Etsy drives organic traffic to quality listings with strong photos and relevant tags. You cannot sell mass-produced goods competitively here.
Shopify: Starts at $29/month. You bring your own traffic — no built-in marketplace audience. Transaction fees are 2% unless you use Shopify Payments. The advantage is full brand control, customer data ownership, and no platform competition on your own store.
Your own website: Free with tools like Webflow, Squarespace, or WordPress + WooCommerce. Works for service businesses or products you sell primarily through referrals and relationships. Not effective for discovery-driven product sales.
When to choose Amazon
Choose Amazon when you have a physical product with proven demand — meaning people are already searching for it and buying similar products. Amazon is a search engine for products, not a discovery platform for new ideas. If your product has clear keywords and your unit economics survive a 15% referral fee plus fulfillment costs, Amazon can produce significant volume quickly. It is not a good choice for custom, handmade, or highly differentiated products.
When to choose Etsy
Choose Etsy when your product is handmade, vintage, custom, or craft-oriented and you want immediate access to buyers who are actively looking for unique items. Etsy's algorithm rewards new listings, so fresh shops with good photos and keyword-rich titles can get traction within days. The platform is also more forgiving of imperfect branding — buyers expect an artisan feel, not a polished brand experience.
When to choose Shopify
Choose Shopify when you are building a brand — not just selling a product. Shopify is the right choice when you plan to run paid ads, build an email list, and create a repeat customer relationship. It requires you to drive your own traffic, which means it is more work upfront but produces a more defensible business. If your goal is a brand that cannot be easily undercut by a cheaper competitor on the same marketplace page, you need to own the storefront.
The verdict
For most product businesses: start where the customers already are, then build your own channel in parallel. If your product fits Etsy, start there. If it fits Amazon, start there. Use those early sales to fund a Shopify store and begin building your email list from marketplace buyers. Within 12 months, your goal should be to own a meaningful percentage of your sales outside of any single marketplace.
How to get started
Etsy setup takes two hours: create your shop, upload 10 listings with five photos each, write titles that include the exact words buyers search for ('personalized leather wallet' not 'unique gift for him'), and price to cover your materials, time, platform fees, and shipping with a 30-40% margin. Amazon requires more setup — seller account, product images on white background, and a decision on FBA vs self-fulfillment — plan a full day for your first listing.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Shopify
Build your own branded online store with full customer data ownership
Etsy
Marketplace for handmade, vintage, and craft products with built-in traffic
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Can I sell on Amazon and Shopify at the same time?
Yes, and many successful product businesses do. Use Amazon for volume and discovery, Shopify for brand and repeat customers. Shopify has a native Amazon integration that syncs inventory across both channels.
What is the biggest mistake new sellers make on Etsy?
Bad photos and generic titles. Etsy's search algorithm heavily weights click-through rate, which is driven by your main photo. Invest in a simple white or neutral background and natural light before anything else.
Apply This in Your Checklist