Stripe vs PayPal vs Square: Best Payment Processors for Your E-Commerce Store

The Quick Answer

For most new e-commerce stores or online sellers, Stripe is usually the best main choice. This is true if you're building on Shopify, WooCommerce, or your own website and need solid tools for online sales. Choose PayPal as an important extra payment option, especially for international buyers or if many of your customers expect it. Square is generally not the top pick for online-only sellers, but it works well if you also sell in person at pop-up markets, events, or local pickups alongside your website.

Side-by-Side Breakdown

Stripe: Generally 2.9% + $0.30 per online transaction. It’s built for internet businesses and integrates smoothly with major e-commerce platforms like Shopify, WooCommerce, and BigCommerce. Stripe offers strong tools for fraud prevention, subscription billing for recurring products (like monthly coffee subscriptions), and supports over 135 currencies. It has top-notch developer tools for custom setups, though most online sellers use its easy pre-built integrations. No monthly fees.

Square: Online transaction fees are typically 2.9% + $0.30, similar to Stripe. Square is famous for its easy-to-use in-person POS (Point of Sale) system and free card readers. Its online store features are simpler and best for businesses that mostly sell face-to-face but need a basic online presence for local pickup or simple shipping. If you mainly sell online, Square's strong points for physical retail won't give you much advantage.

PayPal: Standard online checkout fees are around 3.49% + $0.49 per transaction, which is higher than Stripe or Square for most sales. Rates can be lower for Venmo or PayPal balance payments. PayPal has strong brand trust, especially for online buyers and international sales. It offers services like PayPal Credit ("Pay in 4") that can boost sales. However, its tools for custom website integration can feel less modern than Stripe's. Many buyers expect to see PayPal as an option on any online store.

When to Choose Stripe

You're launching a dedicated e-commerce store on platforms like Shopify, WooCommerce, or a custom website. You need a reliable, scalable payment system that handles online sales smoothly. You plan to offer subscription boxes or recurring product purchases, as Stripe excels at managing repeat billing. Your online store requires strong fraud detection to protect against common e-commerce scams. You want a payment gateway that easily integrates with accounting software and marketing tools, growing with your online business from a small Etsy seller to a bigger brand.

When to Choose Square

You primarily sell physical goods in person at craft fairs, farmers markets, or local pop-ups, and your online store (like a simple Square Online Store) is a secondary sales channel. You need a free or cheap card reader to take payments quickly and easily at your physical selling locations. You're moving from a Facebook Marketplace setup to a local business with occasional online orders for pickup or delivery. If your main business is online, Square's strengths (like hardware for in-person sales) won't be as helpful as a pure e-commerce solution.

When to Choose PayPal

Many of your customers, especially those from Etsy, eBay, or international markets, prefer or expect PayPal as a payment method. You sell products globally and need simple, trusted ways for international buyers to pay, including currency conversion. You want to offer financing options like "PayPal Credit" or "Pay in 4" to help customers buy higher-priced items, which can increase your average order value. For most e-commerce stores, PayPal works best as an additional payment option alongside your primary processor (like Stripe or Shopify Payments) to give customers more choices and build trust.

The Verdict

For the majority of e-commerce and online selling businesses, Stripe (or Shopify Payments, which is built on Stripe) is the best primary payment processor. It's made for online sales, offers great features, and scales well as your store grows. PayPal is nearly essential as a secondary payment option. It builds customer trust, especially for international buyers, and offers useful "buy now, pay later" features. Square is generally not the top choice for pure online-only sellers. It shines brightest for businesses that sell a lot in person and need a simple online store to support those physical sales.

How to Get Started

Stripe (or Shopify Payments): If you're using Shopify, simply activate Shopify Payments from your admin panel – it's powered by Stripe and usually the easiest, lowest-fee option for Shopify stores. For other platforms like WooCommerce or BigCommerce, sign up directly at stripe.com, complete your identity verification, and connect your bank account. Integration is usually done by installing a plugin or app for your e-commerce platform. You can often be accepting payments within hours.

Square: If you decide to use Square for a hybrid online/in-person business, go to squareup.com. Sign up, and then you can set up your free Square Online Store and link it to your inventory. If you need it, order a free magstripe card reader for in-person sales.

PayPal: To add PayPal as an option, go to the payment settings section of your e-commerce platform (Shopify, Etsy, etc.). You'll typically click to connect your PayPal business account. This usually involves logging into PayPal through your store's admin to authorize the connection. This setup process is usually straightforward for all platforms.

RECOMMENDED TOOLS

Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Related Guides