How to Accept Payments for Your First Airbnb or VRBO: Stripe vs PayPal vs Square

The quick answer for new hosts

For your first Airbnb or VRBO, you'll mainly need to process online payments. Stripe is usually the top choice if you plan to take direct bookings through your own website or use a channel manager to handle payments. It's built for handling different payment schedules, like deposits and balances, and integrates well with many booking systems. Square isn't typically a good fit for rentals unless you have a physical front desk to take payments for extra services. PayPal can be a good backup option if you offer direct bookings and some guests prefer it, but it's not ideal as your main system for security deposits or managing complex booking dates.

Side-by-side breakdown for vacation rentals

Stripe: Expect fees around 2.9% + 30 cents for each online payment your guest makes. This includes booking payments, cleaning fees, and any charges for damages. Stripe is great because it connects directly with many vacation rental software tools (like Lodgify, Hostaway, or OwnerRez). This means it can automatically handle security deposit holds, scheduled payments for bookings far in advance, and refunds. It gives you good control over these specific rental needs, often without needing you to do any complex setup yourself if you use a booking manager.

PayPal: Fees are usually higher, around 3.49% + 49 cents per online transaction. Many guests, especially from outside the US, feel safe using PayPal. It's simple to add a PayPal payment button if you have your own booking page. But here's the catch: guests are often sent away from your booking site to PayPal to complete their payment. This extra step can sometimes make guests abandon their booking. More importantly, PayPal isn't great at handling 'pre-authorized' security deposits, which are vital for protecting your property without actually charging the guest's card unless damage occurs.

Square: Online payments cost about 2.9% + 30 cents. In-person swipe/tap is cheaper at 2.6% + 10 cents. Square is really made for businesses with physical locations, like shops or restaurants. For your Airbnb, it's almost never the primary choice. You might only use it if you plan to sell specific items at your rental (like a minibar or local souvenirs) and guests pay on site, or if you take a one-off payment for a late checkout in person. It does not integrate well with booking calendars or short-term rental management for handling deposits or scheduled payments.

When to choose Stripe for your Airbnb

Choose Stripe if you're taking direct bookings through your own website, or if you plan to use a professional Channel Manager or Property Management System (PMS) like Lodgify, Guesty, or Hostaway. Stripe shines here because it can handle the specific payment needs of an Airbnb:

* **Security Deposit Holds:** Stripe lets you "pre-authorize" a guest's credit card for a damage deposit. This holds the amount without actually charging them, then releases it after their stay if there are no problems. This is key for protecting your property. * **Scheduled Payments:** For bookings made far in advance, Stripe can automatically charge a deposit at booking and then the remaining balance closer to the check-in date. This automates your payment collection. * **Refunds and Disputes:** It has clear tools for issuing refunds and helping you respond to "chargebacks" if a guest disputes a charge, which can happen with travel bookings. * **Easy Integration:** Stripe works directly with nearly all major short-term rental software, making your booking process smooth and automated without extra work from you.

When to choose Square for your rental

For most new Airbnb hosts, Square is not the right fit for your main booking payments. Only consider Square if you have a specific plan to accept money *in person* at your rental property. For example:

* If you offer a paid "mini-bar" with snacks and drinks, and guests pay for these items when they leave. * If you have an option for a paid late checkout, and guests settle this fee with you face-to-face. * If you sell small local items or specific add-ons (like a "s'mores kit" or "extra towels package") directly at the property.

You would need to buy a Square card reader. But remember, Square does not handle your booking calendar, online reservations, or security deposits. It's an extra tool for very specific, on-site transactions, not your main payment system for rental income.

The verdict for your first property

For your first Airbnb or VRBO property, Stripe is the clear winner for managing guest payments. It handles the specific needs of short-term rentals like security deposits and scheduled payments, and it connects easily with the booking software you'll likely use. If you offer direct bookings, you might add PayPal as a secondary payment option, especially for international guests who prefer it. Just remember, PayPal is not suitable for handling your security deposits. Square is almost never needed for a new host unless you have a very specific plan to charge guests for services or items directly at the property.

How to get started with payments

To start, sign up for a Stripe account at stripe.com. For a short-term rental, you usually won't make payment links yourself. Instead, you'll connect your Stripe account directly to your chosen booking software or Channel Manager (like Lodgify, Guesty, or Hostaway). Follow their specific setup guide to link Stripe. Before you list your property live, it's wise to do a "test booking" if your system allows. Or, have a trusted friend make a mock booking to ensure all payments, deposits, and refunds work smoothly. If you truly need Square for onsite sales, order their card reader, but this is a secondary concern after setting up your main booking payments.

RECOMMENDED TOOLS

Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Related Guides