Stripe vs. PayPal vs. Square: Choosing Payment Processors for Your First Airbnb or VRBO Property
As a first-time Airbnb or VRBO host, you might think the platforms handle all your money. They do for the main booking, but what about direct bookings, additional services, or security deposits outside the platform? Payment processing fees can eat into your profit. A 0.5% difference on a $300 cleaning fee charged 50 times a year is $75 – and that's just one small fee. This guide helps new hosts choose the right payment processor for these specific needs, avoiding unnecessary costs and headaches.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The Quick Answer for New Airbnb & VRBO Hosts
Choose Stripe if you plan to build your own direct booking website (to avoid platform fees), need to process international guest payments for add-ons, or want a robust system for collecting incidentals like damage fees. Choose Square if you frequently offer *in-person* paid services at your property (e.g., a mini-bar, guided local tours), or need to physically process a card for a security deposit or damage claim. Choose PayPal if your guests specifically request it, especially international travelers, or if you want to offer 'buy now, pay later' for higher-value add-ons or longer direct stays.
Side-by-Side Breakdown for Vacation Rental Payments
Stripe: Generally 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction. Best-in-class tools for integrating with direct booking websites (like Hostaway or Lodgify), supports 135+ currencies for international guests, ideal for subscription-like stays or flexible billing for long-term rentals, no monthly fee. Square: 2.6% + $0.10 for in-person transactions using their free card readers / 2.9% + $0.30 online. Excellent for physical interactions if you offer a local shop or collect payments at check-in. Weaker for robust direct booking website integration. PayPal: 3.49% + $0.49 for standard online checkout (lower for Venmo and PayPal balance). Strong consumer trust, especially globally, but higher standard fees. Good for one-off payment links for incidentals.
When to Choose Stripe for Your First Vacation Rental
You are building your own direct booking website for your first property to reduce reliance on platforms and their booking fees. Stripe integrates smoothly with popular vacation rental website builders (e.g., Smoobu, Guesty for Hosts). You frequently host international guests and need to easily process payments in different currencies for extra services like early check-in fees, late check-out fees, or pet fees. Your goal is to automate payment collection for incidentals (damage claims, extra cleaning) through custom payment links or integrations. Stripe's tools are designed for comprehensive financial management if your rental business grows beyond one property.
When to Choose Square for Your Short-Term Rental
You offer *in-person* paid services directly at your rental property, such as a stocked mini-bar, paid laundry services, or personalized local tours, and need a simple way to take card payments on site. You occasionally need to collect a security deposit or damage fee from a guest *in person* upon check-out or during their stay, and a physical card reader would be convenient. You might have a small 'honor system' shop at your property selling local goods or snacks, and Square provides an easy way to track and process these sales.
When to Choose PayPal for Guest Payments
A significant portion of your guests, especially international travelers, prefer or specifically ask to pay for additional services (e.g., airport transfers, specific amenity requests, extended stays) via PayPal or Venmo. You are using a smaller booking platform or social media to secure direct bookings, and PayPal's simple payment links are easy to share and trustworthy. You want to offer 'PayPal Credit' or 'buy-now-pay-later' options for higher-value add-ons or longer direct bookings, making it easier for guests to afford their stay or additional experiences.
The Verdict for New Airbnb & VRBO Hosts
For new hosts looking to build a direct booking presence or needing flexible, global payment options for supplemental fees outside of Airbnb/VRBO, Stripe is the most robust and versatile choice. Its strong integration capabilities with vacation rental software make it ideal. Square is less common as a primary processor for STRs but can be excellent for very specific *in-person* transactions at your property. PayPal shines as a supplemental payment option for guest convenience, especially for international guests or specific requested payments, though its standard fees are higher than Stripe for general online transactions.
How to Get Started with Your Payment Processor
Stripe: To use Stripe for direct bookings, create an account at stripe.com, complete the identity verification, and then integrate it directly with your chosen vacation rental website builder (many have built-in Stripe options). For simple incidental fees, use Stripe Checkout to create payment links. Square: Sign up at squareup.com. If you plan to take in-person payments, order a free card reader. Set up your service items (like 'late check-out fee' or 'pet fee') in the Square POS app. You can also generate payment links for remote collection. PayPal: Create a PayPal Business account, then generate payment links for specific services or integrate with platforms that support PayPal natively. All three can be set up to accept payments within 24 hours.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Does Stripe have a monthly fee?
No monthly fee for the standard account. Stripe Radar (advanced fraud tools) and some add-ons have separate pricing. You only pay per transaction.
Can I use Stripe and PayPal together?
Yes. Many businesses use Stripe as the primary processor and add PayPal as an optional checkout method. Shopify Payments (powered by Stripe) allows additional payment providers.
What is the risk of account holds?
Both Stripe and PayPal reserve the right to hold funds if your business is flagged as high-risk. Stripe is generally more developer-friendly about communication when this happens. High-risk industries often need a dedicated merchant account instead.