How to Research Legal Market Competition Before Hanging Your Shingle

The Quick Answer

To research legal market competition before opening your firm, run a four-part analysis: (1) Search Martindale-Hubbell and Avvo for every attorney in your practice area and geography, noting ratings, review counts, and years in practice. (2) Audit the Google My Business profiles of your top 10 competitors — review count, response rate, and photo quality reveal how seriously they take digital marketing. (3) Identify the top referral sources (other attorneys, CPAs, real estate agents, social workers) and map which existing firms have those relationships locked up. (4) Search Google for your target keywords to see who's ranking organically and paying for ads. This four-part analysis takes 8–10 hours but will shape every decision you make about positioning, pricing, and marketing.

Using Martindale-Hubbell for Credentialing and Market Mapping

Martindale-Hubbell (martindale.com) is the oldest attorney directory in the U.S. and still carries significant weight with referral sources, particularly other attorneys and corporate clients. Search your practice area and city to identify who the established players are. Look for attorneys with AV Preeminent ratings (the highest peer-review rating) — these are the attorneys whose referral relationships you'll need to understand and eventually cultivate or compete around. Note which firms have been in operation 10+ years versus recent entrants. A market with many new entrants (2–5 years in practice) signals that a wave of new attorneys has already identified the opportunity; a market with mostly 20-year veterans signals entrenched but potentially complacent competition. Also note which firms list multiple attorneys versus true solos — multi-attorney firms often can't profitably serve smaller matters that a lean solo can handle at competitive rates.

Decoding Avvo Ratings and Review Patterns

Avvo scores attorneys on a 1–10 scale based on years in practice, bar memberships, peer endorsements, awards, and disciplinary history. For competitive analysis, sort your local results by number of client reviews — this is the metric most predictive of online conversion, since prospective clients read reviews before calling. An attorney with an Avvo score of 9.2 but only 3 client reviews is less dominant than one with a score of 8.1 and 47 reviews. Map out the top five attorneys by review count in your market. Then read every negative review — these tell you what clients in your market are most frustrated about (poor communication, billing surprises, slow response time). If those same complaints appear across multiple firms, you've identified a service differentiator you can build into your practice from day one. Committing to same-day phone response and transparent billing can set you apart in a market where established attorneys coast on reputation.

Auditing Google My Business Profiles of Competitors

Every serious attorney competitor in your market has (or should have) a Google Business Profile. Search '[practice area] attorney [your city]' and click through the map pack — the three local listings that appear at the top of results. For each competitor, note: total review count, average rating, date of most recent review (stale reviews signal an inactive firm), whether they respond to reviews (most don't, which is an opportunity), and photo count. A competitor with 4.2 stars and 80 reviews who hasn't posted new photos in two years is vulnerable. A competitor with 4.9 stars, 200 reviews, and weekly Google Posts is dominant and will be hard to displace in the near term. Use this audit to identify which competitors are actively investing in their digital presence versus relying on legacy reputation — the latter group is where you can steal market share fastest.

Mapping Referral Networks Before You Open

In most practice areas, referrals from complementary professionals drive 40–70% of a solo attorney's business within the first three years. Family law attorneys get referrals from therapists, mediators, and financial advisors. Estate planning attorneys partner with CPAs, financial planners, and insurance agents. Immigration attorneys receive referrals from HR departments, community organizations, and other attorneys. Before you open, identify the top 20 referral sources in your target practice area and research which existing firms those sources recommend. LinkedIn is invaluable here — search for CPAs or financial planners in your city and look at their activity to see which law firms they mention, attend events with, or publicly endorse. Referral relationships take 6–18 months to build; knowing who controls them now tells you how long your ramp-up will be and where to invest your networking energy first.

Analyzing Paid Search Competition to Gauge Market Investment Levels

Use Google's Keyword Planner or a free trial of SpyFu (spyfu.com) to see how much your competitors are spending on Google Ads. Legal keywords are among the most expensive in any industry: 'personal injury attorney [city]' can cost $50–$300 per click, while 'estate planning attorney [city]' might run $15–$60 per click. A market where the top 5 competitors are all running aggressive ad campaigns means you'll need either a significant paid media budget (plan $2,000–$5,000/month minimum) or a superior organic SEO strategy to compete. If the paid competition is thin — few or no ads showing for your target terms — it signals either low demand (a bad sign) or an opportunity for a first-mover advantage in paid search (a very good sign). This analysis also tells you what your competitors believe a client is worth: if they're paying $200 per click, they're expecting clients worth $3,000–$10,000 minimum.

RECOMMENDED TOOLS

Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS