Independent Building Supply Dealer vs Cooperative Member: Analyzing Do it Best, Ace, and True Value
When launching a building materials or hardware supply business, one of the most consequential early decisions is whether to operate as a fully independent dealer or join a buying cooperative like Do it Best, Ace Hardware, or True Value. The cooperative model reduces some startup risk but comes with margin constraints, branding requirements, and ongoing fees. The independent path gives you complete flexibility but puts full sourcing, marketing, and technology weight on your shoulders. Here is how to analyze both options before signing anything.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
How Hardware Cooperatives Work
Do it Best Corp, Ace Hardware, and True Value are all retailer-owned cooperatives, meaning the dealer-members own the cooperative and share in its profits. When you join, you purchase equity stock in the cooperative (typically $5,000–$25,000 depending on projected volume) and gain access to the cooperative's wholesale buying program, branded marketing, store design standards, and technology platform. Each year the cooperative pays a patronage dividend — essentially a rebate on your purchases — which can run 3–8% of your wholesale buy. Do it Best is the largest in North America with over 4,000 member locations. Ace Hardware has over 5,500 locations worldwide and stronger consumer brand recognition in suburban and rural markets. True Value has approximately 4,500 locations and focuses on hardware and paint, with a lighter building supply emphasis.
Do it Best: The Contractor-Friendly Cooperative
Do it Best Corp positions itself as the most flexible of the three majors — members can operate under the Do it Best brand, a co-brand, or even their own independent name while still accessing cooperative pricing. The buying program covers lumber, building materials, hardware, paint, and seasonal products. Membership requires a stock purchase scaled to your projected annual purchases, typically starting around $5,000–$15,000 for a new location. The annual membership fee is nominal (often under $3,000). Do it Best hosts a semiannual market in Fort Wayne, Indiana where members write orders and access vendor specials. For a building supply dealer adding a retail component, Do it Best's flexibility and building material depth makes it the strongest cooperative fit compared to Ace or True Value, which are more hardware-retail focused.
Ace Hardware: Consumer Brand Power, Stricter Standards
Ace Hardware's cooperative model is more prescriptive than Do it Best — members are expected to operate under the Ace brand, maintain store layout and signage standards, and meet minimum assortment requirements. The consumer brand recognition (Ace is consistently ranked the highest in customer satisfaction among hardware retailers) is real and valuable in markets where homeowner retail traffic matters. Ace membership involves a license fee ($5,000–$10,000), a stock purchase ($5,000–$25,000 based on size), and ongoing royalty fees on retail sales (typically 0.5–1%). If your primary customer is the retail consumer or the light DIY homeowner, Ace's brand pulls meaningful traffic. If your primary customer is the professional contractor, the Ace brand adds less value and the standards add more constraint.
Going Fully Independent: Margin, Flexibility, and Risk
An independent building supply dealer negotiates directly with manufacturers and distributors for each product category. For roofing supply, you negotiate with ABC Supply and Beacon as your primary wholesalers, or directly with GAF and Owens Corning for shingle programs. For lumber, you work directly with Weyerhaeuser, BlueLinx, or regional dealers. For masonry and hardscape, Oldcastle and Belgard have independent dealer programs. The margin upside is real — without cooperative dues and stock commitments, you keep the full spread. The risk is that buying power for commodity items (fasteners, caulk, small tools) is lower without cooperative volume. Most pure specialty dealers (roofing supply, masonry, tile) go independent because cooperative buying programs are not optimized for specialty materials. Most hybrid retail-plus-contractor dealers find cooperative membership worth the cost for the commodity SKUs and brand recognition.
Territory Rights and Competitive Protections
All three major cooperatives offer some form of territory protection or right-of-first-refusal for new locations, but protections vary. Ace Hardware provides exclusive territory rights within a defined radius, typically 1–3 miles in suburban markets. Do it Best does not offer strict exclusive territories but provides location support and discourages member-to-member competition in the same market. True Value offers territory exclusivity for certain store formats. For an independent dealer, there are no territorial protections — a national chain or a second cooperative member can open across the street without constraint. If your market has significant new construction activity and you are concerned about competitive entry, cooperative territory protections offer some limited security. For rural or semi-rural markets, the natural geographic barrier of driving distance is usually protection enough.
Financial Comparison: Year-One Economics
Assume a mid-size building supply dealer projecting $2M in first-year sales. As a Do it Best member purchasing $1.2M wholesale: stock purchase of approximately $12,000, nominal annual fee of $2,500, patronage dividend at year-end of approximately $48,000–$96,000 (4–8% of wholesale purchases). Net cooperative cost after dividend: essentially break-even to modestly positive. As a fully independent dealer purchasing the same $1.2M wholesale: no cooperative fees, but potentially 2–5% higher product costs on commodity items without cooperative volume. For specialty categories (roofing, masonry, tile), independent pricing through manufacturer dealer programs often matches or beats cooperative pricing. The math favors cooperatives for hardware-heavy dealers and independents for specialty-focused dealers. In both cases, the cooperative decision is less about the direct cost and more about whether the brand, technology, and marketing infrastructure accelerates your launch.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Do it Best Corp
Member-owned wholesale buying cooperative for independent hardware and building supply dealers. Request a membership packet to evaluate buying program and stock requirements.
Ace Hardware
Retailer-owned cooperative with strong consumer brand recognition. Best fit for dealers with significant retail homeowner traffic alongside contractor sales.
ZenBusiness
Form your building supply LLC before signing cooperative agreements or supplier credit applications. Fast online formation with registered agent included.
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Can I switch from cooperative to independent after joining?
Yes, but exit terms vary by cooperative. Ace Hardware requires 12–24 months notice and has specific brand wind-down requirements. Do it Best allows members to exit with stock redemption over a defined period, typically 1–3 years. True Value has similar redemption terms. Read the membership agreement carefully before joining and model the exit cost before committing.
Does cooperative membership affect my ability to carry other suppliers?
Cooperatives generally allow members to purchase from non-cooperative sources, but they incentivize in-cooperative purchasing through patronage dividends. Some categories may have preferred vendor programs that encourage exclusive sourcing. For specialty categories like roofing shingles or hardscape, cooperative members routinely supplement with direct manufacturer purchasing outside the cooperative's buying program.
What is the minimum investment to join Do it Best?
Do it Best stock purchase is scaled to your projected annual purchases. New members projecting under $500,000 in annual cooperative purchases typically buy $5,000–$8,000 in stock. Larger new locations may be asked to purchase $15,000–$25,000. The annual dues are nominal — typically under $3,000. Contact Do it Best Corp directly at doitbestcorp.com for current membership requirements.
Apply This in Your Checklist