How to Price Your Products for Online Selling Without Undercutting Yourself
The price tag on your product page isn't the whole story. Many new e-commerce sellers lose profit before a customer even clicks 'add to cart' — in how they calculate costs, present value, handle shipping, and whether they panic-discount too soon. This guide shows you how to get your product pricing right for your Shopify store, Etsy shop, or Amazon listings and present it clearly.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The quick answer
Set your product price based on the value it delivers to the customer, your true costs (including fulfillment), and market demand, not just a guess or what a competitor does. Display the price clearly, explain what it includes (e.g., quality materials, unique design), and let the customer decide. Do not over-explain, qualify, or offer discounts unless it's part of a planned strategy. The goal is not to get every single sale — it's to attract the right customers who value your products at a price that keeps your online business profitable and growing.
Side-by-side breakdown
Weak online pricing: Listing a handcrafted item as '$24.99, but that's just the base price, shipping is extra and depends on your location, and we often run flash sales so maybe wait.' This creates confusion, adds hidden costs, and makes customers hesitate or abandon carts.
Strong online pricing: 'This [product name] is $29.99. It's made with [X high-quality material] and includes [Y unique feature]. We offer free shipping on all orders over $50. Add to cart to see bundle options.' This is clear, confident, and offers value directly. The customer understands the full picture immediately.
When to hold your price
Hold your product price when you've accurately calculated your cost of goods sold (COGS), labor, platform fees (like Etsy listing fees or Shopify transaction fees), and marketing spend, and the price ensures a healthy profit margin (e.g., 20-50% for direct-to-consumer goods). Stick to your price when customer feedback indicates value, when the objection is purely about finding the lowest possible price elsewhere (not about your product's features), or when discounting would mean selling below a sustainable margin. For example, if your vintage t-shirt costs you $15 to source and clean, and you price it at $35, selling for $20 just to get a sale isn't sustainable for your Amazon reseller business.
When a discount is appropriate
Discount when you genuinely need to move old inventory (e.g., end-of-season apparel), when you're launching a new product and need initial reviews (e.g., first 100 Shopify customers get 15% off), or when rewarding customer loyalty (e.g., a 'thank you' discount code for repeat buyers). You can also offer discounts for bulk purchases or as part of a bundle deal (e.g., 'Buy 2, Get 1 Free' on Etsy). Never discount reactively to a customer asking for a lower price on a single item. Make the reason for the discount clear and part of a planned promotion, like 'Clearance Sale: 30% Off Last Season's Collection' or 'New Customer Welcome: 10% Off Your First Order.'
The verdict
The best pricing strategy for e-commerce isn't about convincing every visitor your price is fair. It's about attracting the right customers who understand and appreciate the value of your products. A customer who consistently abandons carts due to your shipping fee might be a different customer than one who buys your premium product but then complains about the price. Focus on qualifying your target audience and ensuring your product description, photos, and branding justify your price before the customer even sees the 'add to cart' button. Understand your competitor's pricing, but don't let it dictate yours if your product offers superior quality or unique benefits.
How to get started
Before listing your next product, accurately calculate all costs: material, labor, packaging, shipping materials, platform fees, payment processing fees, and a portion of your marketing budget. Add your desired profit margin. Then, visit your product page or listing draft. Read your product description and look at your photos. Do they clearly communicate why your product is worth its price? Write down three key benefits or unique selling points that justify your price. Lead with those in your description. For example, 'Hand-poured soy candle with a 60-hour burn time and phthalate-free fragrance.' The customer should understand the superior value before they see the price tag.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
HoneyBook
Build proposals that present your price in the context of your value
Bonsai
Send professional proposals with clear pricing and e-signature
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What do I do if a customer says my price is too high?
Ask: 'Too high compared to what?' This question often reveals the real objection — a different competitor, a budget constraint, or a mismatch in perceived value. From there you can address the actual issue rather than just discounting.
Is it okay to raise my prices on existing clients?
Yes. Give 60-90 days notice, explain the reason briefly (increased costs, scope of service), and frame it around continued partnership. Most established clients accept a 10-20% increase once per year. Losing one price-sensitive client is often better than keeping them at an unsustainable rate.
Apply This in Your Checklist