How to Price Products for Your Online Store (Shopify, Etsy, Amazon Sellers)
Just because another Shopify seller or Etsy shop lists an item at a certain price doesn't mean it's the right price for you. Many online sellers copy competitor prices, then struggle with low profits or getting ignored. This guide shows you how to use competitor pricing for your online store as smart data, not a fixed target, so you can price for profit and stand out.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The quick answer
Research competitors to see what similar products sell for on platforms like Etsy, Shopify stores, or Amazon. This shows you the general price customers expect. But don't just copy their price. First, calculate your true costs – product, packaging, shipping, platform fees (like Etsy's 6.5% transaction fee or Shopify's 2.9% + $0.30 credit card fee). Then, add what your unique offer is worth (e.g., faster shipping, custom designs, better warranty). Use this to set your base price, then check if it fits the market range.
Side-by-side breakdown
Direct research means visiting competitor storefronts: other Shopify stores selling similar items, Etsy shops, Amazon product listings, even eBay or Facebook Marketplace for used goods. Add items to your cart to see shipping costs, taxes, and any hidden fees. Note their product variations, bundle deals, and ongoing sales. This shows public prices, but won't tell you their wholesale cost or special bulk discounts.
Indirect research involves reading customer reviews on Amazon, Etsy, or product pages. Customers often complain about price or praise good value. Join niche Facebook groups or Reddit communities (like r/Etsy, r/shopify) where buyers discuss products and pricing. Watch YouTube unboxing videos; prices are often mentioned.
Primary research is asking your target customers directly. Run a poll on Instagram stories: 'What would you pay for a handmade candle that burns for 60 hours?' Or send a short survey to your email list asking what they've paid for similar items recently. This gives you the most honest price feedback.
When competitor pricing is useful
Competitor pricing helps you see if your product price fits within what online buyers expect. If similar artisan jewelry sells for $30-70, and you want to charge $5, you're too low and might seem cheap. If you want to charge $150, you need a very clear reason why (e.g., real gold, intricate design). It also shows you gaps. Maybe everyone sells individual prints, but no one offers a framed print subscription box. This could be your niche. Finally, it tells you what customers expect as standard (like free shipping over $75) versus what they'll pay more for (like express shipping or gift wrapping).
When to ignore competitor pricing
Don't let competitor pricing trap you when your online product is truly different. If you sell handcrafted, sustainably sourced leather bags, don't compare yourself to mass-produced PU leather bags on Amazon. Your buyers value different things. Ignore prices if you target a high-end buyer who wants luxury, while competitors aim for budget shoppers. Also, if other sellers are clearly selling at prices so low they can't be making a profit (e.g., selling handmade items for less than the cost of materials and minimum wage), ignore them. Their business won't last. Finally, if your offer includes extra value like personalized engraving, premium packaging, or a unique online experience, your price won't directly compare to a bare-bones product listing.
The verdict
Always research competitor pricing before you launch a new product on Shopify, Etsy, or Amazon. List out similar products and their prices, from the cheapest to the most expensive. Figure out what makes the highest-priced items worth more (e.g., unique materials, custom artwork, fast shipping, strong brand reputation). Then, calculate your own costs (materials, labor, shipping, platform fees) and add your desired profit and the value of your unique offer. Set your price using your numbers first, then compare it to the market range you mapped. Don't start by trying to beat the lowest price.
How to get started
To start, create a simple spreadsheet. Make columns for: 'Platform' (Etsy, Shopify, Amazon), 'Seller Name/Store', 'Specific Product', 'Base Price', 'Shipping Cost', 'Key Features/Value' (e.g., free shipping, custom options, unique materials), and 'Who it's for' (e.g., budget buyers, luxury gifts). Find 5-10 direct competitors selling very similar items. Pay close attention to the highest-priced options: what makes them special? This small task, done in an hour or two, will give you a clear picture of your market and help you price confidently.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Semrush
Research competitor positioning, keywords, and who they are targeting
SpyFu
See competitors' paid keywords — often reveals their pricing strategy
Google Trends
Track demand shifts in your product category
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What if no competitors publish their pricing?
Call them as a prospect. Most sales conversations will yield at least a range. Review G2, Capterra, and Reddit for price mentions. Ask your prospects: 'What are you currently paying to solve this problem?' — that reveals the effective market rate better than any published pricing page.
Should I be the cheapest option in my market?
Almost never. The cheapest position attracts the most price-sensitive customers, produces the thinnest margins, and makes you the first to lose clients when a competitor cuts further. Price for the segment you want, not for everyone.
Apply This in Your Checklist