Next vs Hiscox vs Simply Business: Best Short-Term Rental Insurance for New Hosts
A single incident—like a guest slipping on wet tile, an appliance breaking, or even just a bad review causing lost bookings—can quickly become a major financial headache for your Airbnb or VRBO. Getting the right insurance is crucial, but overpaying for coverage you don't need wastes money you could use for property upgrades or marketing your listing. This guide cuts through the noise to help first-time hosts choose the best short-term rental insurance to protect their property and income.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The quick answer
Next Insurance is the fastest choice for straightforward short-term rental liability, meaning coverage for guest injuries or property damage *to others* caused by guests—you can get a policy in under 10 minutes. Hiscox is less of a direct fit for typical first-time Airbnb hosts focused solely on property rental, as its strength is professional liability, which isn't a primary need for most new hosts. Simply Business is a comparison marketplace; use it when you need to see multiple quotes for comprehensive short-term rental policies, including property damage to your own unit and loss of income.
Side-by-side breakdown
Next Insurance: online-only, instant quotes for general liability, often starts around $25-$35/month for a small apartment or spare room. No phone sales required, certificate of insurance downloadable immediately. Best for: new Airbnb hosts needing quick guest liability protection for slips, falls, or minor guest-caused property damage to a neighbor.
Hiscox: specialist small business insurer, strong in professional liability (E&O). While they can offer general liability, it's not their primary focus for pure short-term rentals. Monthly payment options. Best for: hosts who also offer paid advisory services to guests (e.g., guided tours, local investment advice) or manage multiple properties as a professional service provider—less ideal for the typical first-time host just renting a single property.
Simply Business: broker marketplace, not a direct insurer. Gets you quotes from multiple carriers including Markel, Travelers, and others. Useful for comparing 'apples to apples' on more complex needs. Best for: any host who isn't sure which specific coverages they need (beyond basic liability), or who needs a comprehensive package including dedicated short-term rental property insurance, bed bug coverage, loss of income, or commercial auto if offering guest transport.
When to choose Next Insurance
Choose Next when you need general liability coverage fast for your first short-term rental. This means protecting against common risks like a guest slipping on a wet patio, tripping on a rug, or accidentally breaking a neighbor's window. Next is strong if you work in a simple rental model and want to manage everything online without talking to an agent. It's also easy to add an 'additional insured' like an HOA or property management company if your building requires proof of your liability coverage.
When to choose Hiscox
For most first-time short-term rental hosts, Hiscox's primary strength in professional liability isn't the most direct fit. General liability doesn't cover you if a guest claims your specific advice (e.g., a restaurant recommendation, a local activity suggestion) led to an injury or loss—that's E&O territory. Choose Hiscox if your rental business involves offering distinct paid services or advice beyond just providing accommodation, or if you plan to expand into managing multiple properties for other owners. For pure guest liability and property damage, other providers might be more cost-effective.
When to use Simply Business
Use Simply Business when you're not sure exactly what types of coverage your short-term rental needs, or when your situation is more complex than just basic guest liability. This is especially true if you need dedicated short-term rental property insurance (which most standard homeowner policies exclude), coverage for loss of income due to property damage, or specific protections against risks like theft by guests, bed bug infestations, or liquor liability if you offer complimentary alcohol. Simply Business compares carriers to help you find a comprehensive policy that covers all your unique short-term rental risks.
The verdict
For basic guest liability protection for your first Airbnb or VRBO property, start with Next Insurance for its speed and online convenience. If your short-term rental operation involves professional advice or management services for others, Hiscox might be relevant for those specific business aspects. However, if you need a comprehensive package, including property-specific coverage for your own unit, or want to compare options for complex scenarios (e.g., a unique property, or an old home with specific risks), run Simply Business first. Do not skip this step—operating your short-term rental without adequate liability and property coverage is the single fastest way to lose everything you have built.
How to get started
1. Identify your core coverage needs: general liability (for guest injuries/damage to others), and critically, dedicated short-term rental *property* insurance (to cover damage *to your own unit* and potential loss of income). 2. Get a quick general liability quote from Next Insurance for immediate guest protection. 3. If you need property-specific coverage, or if the initial quote feels thin for your specific risks (e.g., a property with a pool, high-value art, or an older home), use Simply Business to compare comprehensive short-term rental policies from multiple carriers. 4. Purchase your policy and ensure it's active *before* your first guest checks in. 5. Download your Certificate of Insurance (COI) and save it. You might need to provide it to your HOA, mortgage lender, or the booking platform (if they ask).
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Next Insurance
Instant online quotes — coverage in minutes
Hiscox
Best for professional services and E&O coverage
Simply Business
Compare multiple carriers side by side
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Do I need business insurance if I am an LLC?
Yes. An LLC protects your personal assets from business debts, but it does not protect you from liability claims arising from your work. If a client sues you, the LLC limits personal exposure but the business itself still needs insurance to cover legal costs and settlements.
What is the difference between general liability and professional liability?
General liability covers bodily injury and property damage — someone trips and falls at your event, for example. Professional liability (E&O) covers claims that your work, advice, or service caused financial harm to a client. Most service businesses need both.
How much does small business insurance cost?
General liability for a low-risk service business typically starts at $25-50/month. Professional liability adds $30-80/month depending on your profession and revenue. Bundled policies (BOP) can be more cost-effective for businesses with physical locations.
Apply This in Your Checklist