Hiring Your First Subcontractors vs Employees for a Remodeling Business

The Quick Answer

Use 1099 subcontractors for specialized trades you don't perform yourself — plumbers, electricians, tile setters, HVAC technicians — where they work for multiple clients, set their own schedule, and supply their own tools. Hire W-2 employees when you need someone showing up at your direction, on your schedule, using your tools, every day. Misclassifying an employee as a 1099 sub exposes you to IRS back taxes (employer FICA, unpaid withholding), state labor agency penalties, and workers' comp liability. When in doubt, consult a construction-savvy CPA or employment attorney before classifying someone as a 1099.

The IRS 1099 vs W-2 Classification Test

The IRS uses a multi-factor behavioral and financial control test to determine whether a worker is an employee (W-2) or an independent contractor (1099). Key factors favoring independent contractor status: the worker controls how the work is done (not just the result), the worker has multiple clients simultaneously, the worker supplies their own tools and equipment, the worker can hire their own helpers, and the relationship is not permanent. Key factors favoring employee status: you control when and how they work, they work exclusively for you, you provide the tools, and you pay a regular weekly wage. In construction, state agencies (especially California's EDD, New York's DOL, and Massachusetts's AG) have stricter tests than the IRS. California's ABC test presumes all workers are employees unless you can pass all three prongs — including proving the worker performs work 'outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business,' which is nearly impossible for a general contractor claiming tile setters are independent. Get state-specific advice.

Building Your Subcontractor Team

A typical residential remodeling contractor relies on a team of trusted subs for: plumbing rough-in and trim-out ($85–$150/hour for a licensed plumber or $3,500–$8,000 per typical bathroom rough-in), electrical rough-in and trim-out ($75–$130/hour or $2,500–$6,000 per typical kitchen rough-in), tile setting ($8–$18/sq ft labor for standard tile; $15–$30/sq ft for large-format or complex patterns), painting ($25–$50/sq ft for interior paint labor or $2,000–$6,000 for a full kitchen), cabinet installation ($500–$2,500 for a standard kitchen depending on scope), and countertop fabrication and installation ($40–$120/sq ft for quartz; typically handled by the countertop company). Finding qualified subs: ask other contractors at your local NARI chapter, ask your material suppliers (Ferguson reps know the best plumbers and electricians in your market), and use Houzz Pro's directory to find specialists. LinkedIn and local trade association websites are also productive. Always verify license and insurance before awarding any subcontract.

Subcontractor Agreements: What to Include

A written subcontractor agreement is essential — never rely on a handshake. Your sub agreement should include: scope of work (specific to the project — not a generic description), pricing (lump sum or hourly rate, with not-to-exceed amount if hourly), payment terms (typically paid within 7–10 days of invoice receipt and your draw collection from the client), insurance requirements (GL and workers' comp minimums — require COIs before any work begins), license verification statement (sub confirms they hold current, valid licenses), workmanship warranty (typically one year on their labor), change order process, lien waiver requirements (sub provides conditional lien waiver with each invoice, unconditional at final payment), and a clause stating the worker is an independent contractor and not an employee. Have a construction attorney draft your master subcontractor agreement — it will be used for every sub relationship and is worth the $300–$600 legal investment.

Workers' Compensation for Subcontractors

Workers' comp for subcontractors is the most legally complex area of contractor HR. The general rule: if your sub has their own workers' comp policy covering their employees (and themselves, if they've elected coverage), you're protected. If they don't, and they're injured on your job site, you may be held liable for their medical costs and lost wages — even if they're legitimately classified as an independent contractor. Your defense: require a current certificate of insurance from every sub before work begins, verify the policy is active (not expired) by calling the insurance carrier, and re-verify COIs at the start of every new project. In states like California, Florida, and New York, sub workers' comp verification is scrutinized aggressively. Consider adding a contract provision that shifts the cost of any uninsured injury back to the sub. Your Buildertrend subcontractor management module includes a COI tracking feature — use it.

When to Hire Your First W-2 Employee

Hire a W-2 employee — typically a carpenter or general laborer — when you consistently need someone on-site five days a week, working under your direct supervision, using your tools, and not working for other contractors. The cost of a W-2 employee beyond their wage: employer FICA taxes (7.65% of wages), federal and state unemployment taxes (FUTA/SUTA, 1–5% of wages up to the wage base), workers' comp insurance (8–18% of wages in construction), and potentially health insurance (if you offer it). On a $55,000 annual wage for a carpenter, your true fully-loaded cost is $68,000–$80,000. The benefit: a reliable, trained team member who executes your standards every day, who grows with your business, and who enables you to take on larger projects with predictable labor capacity. Most remodeling contractors hire their first W-2 employee between $400K–$600K in annual revenue, when the workload justifies the overhead.

RECOMMENDED TOOLS

Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS