Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll vs ADP: Best Payroll Software for Self-Employed Tradesmen
You just left your employer and launched your own roofing, plumbing, or flooring business. You're thinking about your first big job, your truck payment, and tool costs, not payroll. But payroll mistakes – whether for yourself, a 1099 subcontractor, or your first W-2 helper – can cost you more than a new impact driver. Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll, and ADP can handle the paperwork, but they're built for different types of trade businesses. This guide helps you pick the right one for your solo operation.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The quick answer for tradesmen
Use Gusto if you want the easiest platform to pay yourself (as an owner), file 1099s for subcontractors, and easily handle your first W-2 employee. It's built for small teams. Use QuickBooks Payroll if you already run your bids, invoices, and expense tracking through QuickBooks Online and want all your finances in one place. Use ADP only if you plan to grow very fast and hire a large crew (25+ W-2 employees) in your first year, needing top-tier compliance support from day one – most solo tradesmen won't need this initially.
Side-by-side breakdown for your trade business
Gusto starts at $40/month plus $6/person (owner, 1099 sub, or W-2 employee). It handles payroll for you, benefits, worker's comp integration (a big deal for trades), 1099 and W-2 filing, and new hire reporting across the country. Its interface is clean and simple – less time on paperwork, more time on the job. HR features like simple contract signing are useful for managing subcontractors.
QuickBooks Payroll starts at $45/month plus $5/person. Its main strength is how it works with QuickBooks accounting. If you use QuickBooks Online to track your material costs, send invoices, or manage your truck's mileage, payroll entries automatically post to your books. This combined workflow saves you significant time at month-end, so you can spend more time bidding new jobs or working on existing ones.
ADP is built for much larger companies (ADP Run, starting around $59/month). It has the strongest compliance and legal support, 24/7 help, and can manage complex situations like multi-state jobs with varying labor laws. Its system is more complex to learn, but it's very reliable for big operations. For a solo roofer or plumber, it’s usually overkill and too expensive for what you need starting out.
When to choose Gusto for your solo trade
Gusto is the right choice for most solo tradesmen, especially if you're just starting out, paying yourself, and occasionally bringing on 1099 subcontractors or your first W-2 apprentice. It's easy to set up and handles all the tax filings for you, including quarterly payroll taxes and end-of-year forms (W-2s, 1099s). Its features, like quick employee setup and benefits integration (should you grow and offer them), go beyond what QuickBooks Payroll offers for pure payroll, all for a straightforward price. It integrates well with accounting software like QuickBooks and Xero, even if you don't use their payroll version.
When to choose QuickBooks Payroll for your trade
Choose QuickBooks Payroll if you already use QuickBooks Online (QBO) to run your plumbing, electrical, or flooring business. If you track materials, create estimates, send invoices, and manage expenses in QBO, adding QuickBooks Payroll means all your financial data is in one place. The automatic sync of payroll entries saves you or your bookkeeper a lot of time and makes sure your job costing and profit tracking are always accurate. This can be crucial for knowing if that big kitchen remodel or roofing job truly made you money.
When to choose ADP for your growing crew
ADP is overkill for most solo tradesmen. It’s worth the higher price only if you plan to hire a large crew (25+ W-2 employees) very quickly, operate across many states with complex labor laws from the start, or need dedicated HR help around the clock. Their compliance team and risk management tools are the strongest, but for a one-man (or woman) shop, or even a small team of 2-5, its cost and complexity are usually too much. Save ADP for when your business scales from a few vans to a whole fleet.
The verdict for tradesmen
If you're a solo tradesman or just hired your first helper, and you're not locked into QuickBooks accounting: Gusto. If you already manage your bids, invoices, and expenses through QuickBooks Online: QuickBooks Payroll. If you're building a massive multi-state operation with a large crew from day one: ADP (but this is rare for first-time solo tradesmen).
How to get started
Sign up for Gusto's free trial. It's designed to walk you through setting up your own owner payroll, adding a 1099 subcontractor, or onboarding your first W-2 employee. The whole process to enter your business details, bank accounts, and tax IDs takes about 45 minutes – less time than picking up materials for a job. Your first payroll usually completes within 4 business days. If you go with QuickBooks Payroll, you can add it directly from your existing QuickBooks Online account settings.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Gusto
Payroll, benefits, and HR for US small businesses
Deel
International contractor and employee payments
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Does Gusto file payroll taxes automatically?
Yes. Gusto calculates, withholds, and remits federal and state payroll taxes automatically. It also files W-2s at year end and handles new hire reporting in all 50 states.
Can I switch payroll providers mid-year?
Yes, but it is complex. You will need to transfer year-to-date payroll data to the new provider so W-2s are accurate. Most providers have migration guides. Switching at the start of a new quarter reduces the complexity.
What is the penalty for late payroll tax deposits?
IRS failure-to-deposit penalties range from 2% to 15% of the unpaid amount depending on how late the deposit is. Even one business day late can trigger a penalty. Automated payroll systems prevent this by depositing taxes on the same day payroll is processed.
Apply This in Your Checklist