Payroll for Personal Errands & Concierge: Gusto vs ADP vs Paychex
For personal errand and concierge services—whether you're paying errand runners, personal shoppers, or senior companions—getting payroll wrong can quickly become a big problem. Misclassifying an "independent contractor" who should be an "employee," missing tax deadlines, or messing up W-2s means fines and headaches down the road. Picking the right payroll system early on isn't just about saving time; it's about protecting your business from costly mistakes.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The Quick Answer
Gusto is best for most personal errand and concierge services, especially those with 1-10 errand runners, personal shoppers, or senior companions. Choose it if you want simple online software, easy setup for hourly pay and mileage, and basic onboarding for new hires. It handles W2 employees and 1099 contractors smoothly, which is common in this field.
ADP is for concierge services growing fast, operating in multiple cities or states, or those with specific needs like complex shift differentials or a large fleet of W2 drivers. It offers deep customization for more complex pay structures.
Paychex is for owners who prefer a dedicated person to manage their payroll completely, rather than doing it themselves through software. Ideal for owners who want to focus purely on client service and delegate all payroll tasks.
Side-by-Side Breakdown
Gusto: Starts around $40/month base + $6/person (employee or contractor). It's self-serve, making it easy to set up payroll for a few errand runners or senior companions. Includes tools for offer letters, simple onboarding checklists, and tracking PTO for your W2 staff. Support via chat and phone. Best for mobile service businesses with 1-10 people needing straightforward payroll, mileage tracking, and contractor payments.
ADP Run: Price is custom, often $60-$200/month or more for even a small team. Setup is guided. Offers many add-ons for HR, like background checks for companions or complex scheduling tools. You can often get a dedicated support person. Best for concierge services expecting rapid growth or those with a dozen+ employees, especially if you have a mix of hourly, salaried, and contractor roles across different regions.
Paychex Flex: Custom pricing, typically $60-$160/month. A representative helps with setup. Good HR features, including simple ways to offer a retirement plan if your service grows. You get a dedicated account manager. Best for errand service owners who want to hand off all payroll tasks, ensuring someone else handles the details, freeing you up to manage clients and tasks.
When to Choose Gusto
Gusto is ideal for most personal errand and concierge service owners, especially if you're just starting to hire your first W2 errand runner or senior companion. Setting up hourly pay, mileage reimbursements, and processing tips is straightforward. Its automated tax filing means you won't miss deadlines for federal or state payroll taxes. For your W2 staff, basic HR tools like sending offer letters, setting up onboarding steps, and tracking paid time off (PTO) are included, which other services often charge extra for. It also makes paying your 1099 independent contractors (like a specialized personal shopper or event assistant) very simple, handling their 1099-NEC forms automatically at year-end.
When to Choose ADP
ADP becomes a strong choice if your concierge service grows significantly, like managing a large team of W2 drivers across several cities or states, each with different local tax rules. If you have complex pay structures, such as varying rates for peak hours, specialized services, or intricate PTO accruals for long-term senior companions, ADP can handle it. For example, if you expand to offer medical transport in addition to errands and need specific compliance for drivers, ADP is built for that. Be ready for custom pricing and a longer setup process, but you gain robust support and a system designed for high-volume, complex payroll.
When to Choose Paychex
Paychex is a good fit for personal errand and concierge service owners who prefer to have a dedicated human handle all their payroll tasks. If you'd rather focus completely on client service and growing your business than logging into software to process payroll each week, Paychex's account manager model is for you. You get a direct person to contact for questions about paying a new errand runner, managing tip reporting, or setting up a simple retirement plan for your team. This can be a huge time-saver if you value a hands-off approach and direct personal support.
The Verdict
For most personal errand and concierge services, start with Gusto. It easily manages hourly workers, mileage, tips, and both W2 employees and 1099 contractors. It's affordable and straightforward to use, saving you time usually spent on admin. If your service expands rapidly with very complex pay rules or many locations, then look at ADP. Choose Paychex if you specifically want a dedicated person to completely manage your payroll for you, so you can focus 100% on your clients and staff.
How to Get Started
For Gusto: Sign up directly on their website. You can often run your first payroll for your errand runners or personal shoppers within a day. Have ready your business EIN, any state tax IDs (like for unemployment or withholding), your company bank account details, and basic info for each person you pay (name, address, pay rate, start date, W-4/W-9).
For ADP or Paychex: You'll need to request a custom quote. Expect a sales call to discuss your specific needs (number of employees/contractors, service locations, desired HR features). Pricing will depend on your team size, where your business operates, and which features you choose.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Gusto
Best payroll software for small business — automated taxes, HR tools included
ADP
Enterprise-grade payroll for growing and complex businesses
Paychex
Full-service payroll with dedicated account manager support
Rippling
Payroll, HR, and IT management in one platform for scaling teams
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Do I need payroll software if I am the only employee?
If you elect S-Corp treatment and pay yourself a salary, yes. If you are a single-member LLC taxed as a sole proprietor, you take owner draws and do not run payroll. Gusto handles both scenarios.
Can I switch payroll providers mid-year?
Yes, but it requires careful coordination to ensure year-to-date records transfer correctly. January 1 transitions are cleanest. Gusto makes switching relatively easy with a payroll history import tool.
What happens if I miss a payroll tax deposit?
The IRS charges penalties starting at 2% for deposits 1-5 days late, escalating to 10% or more for deposits over 15 days late. This is why software that handles deposits automatically matters.
Apply This in Your Checklist