Delivery Platform Pricing Strategy: How to Price Your Menu on DoorDash, UberEats, and Grubhub Without Losing Money
Every delivery order is a negotiation you already lost — DoorDash, UberEats, and Grubhub take 25–30% of every transaction before the customer's payment reaches your account. Without a deliberate pricing strategy, that commission eats through your margins and turns delivery into a volume game you cannot win. Here is how profitable fast-casual operators structure their delivery menus to stay in the black.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The Quick Answer
Price your delivery menu 10–15% higher than your in-store menu. On a $13.49 in-store bowl, charge $14.99–$15.49 on delivery. This narrows the commission hit from 28 points to 13–15 points, making delivery a profitable supplement rather than a margin drain. Combine this with a delivery-optimized menu (fewer items, higher-margin only), proper packaging investment, and a direct ordering link in every delivery bag to capture repeat customers at zero commission cost.
Commission Math: What You Actually Keep
DoorDash's standard restaurant plan charges 25% commission on delivery orders and 6–15% on pickup orders. UberEats charges 15–30% depending on plan tier (Lite, Plus, Premium). Grubhub charges 10–15% for basic marketing plus delivery fees. On a $15 bowl at 27% average commission: you receive $10.95 from the platform. Subtract: food cost $4.65 (31%), packaging $0.60, and allocated labor $2.50 (based on prep time) — you have $3.20 contribution margin per order. At 50 orders per day, that is $160 in daily margin toward kitchen rent, overhead, and profit. At 15% delivery markup ($15.99 delivery price, same bowl): you receive $11.67, keeping $3.92 per order — a 23% improvement in contribution margin without changing a single ingredient. That difference at 50 orders per day is $36/day, $1,080/month, $12,960/year.
Delivery-Optimized Menu Design
Your full dine-in or counter menu should not be your delivery menu. A delivery-optimized menu has 8–15 items (not 25+), focuses on items that travel well (bowls, burritos, sandwiches, wings — not items that go soggy or separate in transit), includes only your highest-margin stars (eliminate dogs entirely), and removes items requiring complex plating that adds labor cost without delivery value. Remove fountain drinks from delivery (they don't travel well and suppress margin) and replace with bottled beverages at higher per-unit margin. Add a delivery-exclusive 'Meal Deal' bundle at $19.99–$23.99 that increases average order value and gives customers a reason to skip the single-item order.
Platform Promotional Credits: How to Use Them Strategically
DoorDash offers new restaurant marketing credits of $250–$500 (sometimes up to $1,000 in high-competition markets) to boost early visibility. UberEats has similar new restaurant promotional packages. These credits fund discounts to customers — the platform absorbs part of the discount cost. Use these credits strategically in your first 30–60 days to generate volume and reviews quickly, then transition off discounting once you have established organic ranking. Do not use platform credits to permanently subsidize a price point you cannot sustain. Run DashPass (DoorDash) or Eats Pass (UberEats) promotions only if your average order value is above $18 — below that, the commission discount benefit is eaten by increased volume of low-ticket orders.
Exclusive Platform Deals: Pros, Cons, and Negotiating
DoorDash's exclusive partnership ('DashPass Exclusive') program offers commission reductions of 5–10 percentage points in exchange for being listed exclusively on DoorDash for a contract period (typically 6–12 months). The commission savings are real — a 5-point reduction on 500 monthly orders at $15 average saves $375/month. But exclusivity costs you UberEats and Grubhub revenue, which combined can represent 30–40% of a restaurant's delivery orders in competitive markets. Evaluate exclusivity deals only if DoorDash represents 70%+ of your current delivery revenue and the commission reduction is at least 5 points. Negotiate: ask for 6-month terms instead of 12, ask for marketing placement guarantees (carousel features, email campaigns) in addition to commission reduction, and retain the right to offer direct online ordering commission-free.
Direct Ordering: Your Long-Term Exit From Commission Dependency
Every delivery order is an opportunity to convert a platform customer into a direct customer — someone who orders through your website or app and pays you 100% of the ticket. Include a direct ordering card in every delivery bag: your website URL, a QR code linking to your Toast Online or Square Online ordering page, and a loyalty offer ('Order direct and get free chips with your next order'). Over 12 months, even converting 10–15% of delivery customers to direct ordering can reduce your effective commission rate from 27% to 22% of total delivery revenue. Toast Online Ordering and Square Online both charge zero per-order commission — you pay only your credit card processing fee (2.6–2.9%).
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Toast POS
Built-in online ordering with zero commission — convert delivery customers to direct orders and keep 100% of the ticket
Square for Restaurants
Commission-free online ordering with Google integration — ideal for fast-casual concepts building direct ordering channels
Olo
Enterprise-grade online ordering and delivery management platform — integrates with all major delivery platforms and your own direct channel
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Is it legal to charge more on delivery apps than in-store?
Yes, in most U.S. markets. There is no law requiring price parity between in-store and delivery menus for independent restaurants. Some platform contracts historically required price parity, but FTC scrutiny and state legislation (California, New York) have largely eliminated enforced price parity clauses. Check your specific platform agreement, but delivery menu markups are now standard practice industry-wide.
Which delivery platform is best for a new fast-casual restaurant?
DoorDash has the largest U.S. market share (roughly 65% of U.S. delivery orders) and should be your first priority. Add UberEats second — it has strong penetration in urban markets and airports. Add Grubhub last, as its market share has declined significantly but it still delivers incremental volume in Midwest and Northeast markets. Use all three initially, then consolidate to your top two performers after 90 days.
How do I handle refunds and complaints on delivery platforms?
Delivery platforms automatically issue refunds for customer complaints about missing items, quality, or incorrect orders and charge them back to your restaurant. Build a $200–$400 monthly line item for platform chargebacks into your financial model. Minimize chargebacks by using printed order stickers on bags (shows correct items were included), double-checking orders before handoff, and investing in quality packaging that keeps food intact during transit.