Where to Start Selling Online: Etsy, Amazon, or Shopify for Your First E-Commerce Store

The quick answer

If you sell handmade jewelry, custom apparel, or vintage items, start on Etsy. You get immediate buyers looking for unique products. If you resell mass-market products like electronics, health supplements, or private label goods, start on Amazon. Customers are already searching for these items. If you are building a brand around your products and plan to market them, start with Shopify. You control the entire customer experience. For products you sell mainly through referrals or social media, a simple website might be enough, but it won't bring new buyers.

Side-by-side breakdown

Amazon has over 300 million active buyers ready to purchase. Fees are typically 8-15% referral fee (e.g., electronics are 8%, clothing is 17%) on each sale, plus FBA fulfillment fees if you use their warehouses. For a small item like a phone case, FBA fees might be $3-5. The big upside: customers are already searching for products. The downside: fierce competition, Amazon owns the customer data, and constant price wars. You cannot easily build an email list.

Etsy draws over 90 million active buyers specifically seeking handmade, vintage, or craft items. You pay a $0.20 listing fee per item (good for four months) and a 6.5% transaction fee on the sale price. Etsy helps drive traffic to well-optimized listings. This means using high-quality photos (taken with good lighting, possibly a DSLR or modern smartphone) and specific keywords in your titles and tags (e.g., "personalized leather wallet" not just "wallet"). You won't succeed selling mass-produced items here.

Shopify plans start at $29/month for the Basic plan. You are responsible for bringing your own customers; Shopify provides no built-in audience. Transaction fees are 2% unless you use Shopify Payments (then it's 0%). The main benefits: complete brand control, owning your customer email list, and no competitors listed next to your products. You can integrate apps like Printful for dropshipping custom t-shirts or ShipStation for efficient shipping.

Building your own website with tools like Squarespace or WordPress (using WooCommerce) can be low-cost. However, it's best for selling specific products through referrals, local pickup, or direct social media outreach. It's not effective for getting new customers who don't already know about your brand. This option works if you're selling a very niche product to an existing audience, not for discovery.

When to choose Amazon

Pick Amazon if you sell physical products with clear demand. Think private label coffee mugs, branded t-shirts, or generic phone accessories. Customers use Amazon like a search engine: they know what they want and type it in. If your product has clear keywords (e.g., "stainless steel water bottle") and your profit margins can handle the 8-15% referral fee plus FBA shipping costs (which can be $3-10 per item), Amazon can bring huge sales volumes fast. It's not for unique, handmade items where branding is key.

When to choose Etsy

Choose Etsy if your products are handmade jewelry, custom pet portraits, vintage home decor, or craft supplies. You get immediate access to buyers actively looking for unique items. Etsy rewards new shops and listings. A new shop can get sales fast by uploading 10-15 high-quality listings with excellent photos (bright, clear, showing detail) and keyword-rich titles and tags (e.g., "custom engraved wooden sign" instead of "cool gift"). Buyers on Etsy expect an artisan feel, not a polished corporate brand.

When to choose Shopify

Go with Shopify when you are building a strong brand around your products. This is for dropshipping custom apparel, selling niche beauty products, or a unique gadget. Shopify is built for long-term customer relationships. You plan to run Facebook Ads or Google Shopping campaigns, capture customer emails for newsletters, and build a community. It takes more upfront effort to drive traffic, but you create a defensible business. Your goal is a brand that can't be easily copied or pushed out by cheaper competitors on a marketplace.

The verdict

For most new online sellers: start where your target customers already shop. If your product is a fit for Etsy, launch there first. If it's a fit for Amazon, start there. Use those initial sales and profits (e.g., $500-$1000) to invest in a Shopify store. Begin building your own brand, email list, and social media presence. Within your first year, aim to get at least 30-40% of your sales directly through your own Shopify store, reducing reliance on any single marketplace.

How to get started

Etsy setup: Plan 2-3 hours. Create your shop, upload at least 10-15 high-quality listings. Each listing needs 5-10 clear photos (use a tripod for consistency). Write titles and tags with specific keywords buyers type (e.g., "handmade ceramic mug," "personalized leather wallet for men"). Price your items to cover material costs, your time, Etsy fees ($0.20 listing, 6.5% transaction), shipping costs, and a target profit margin of 40-60%.

Amazon setup: Plan a full day or more. Set up your Seller Central account. Get professional product images on a pure white background. Decide between FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) where they store and ship, or FBM (Fulfillment by Merchant) where you ship yourself. For FBA, you'll need to prepare and label inventory according to Amazon's strict guidelines.

Shopify setup: Plan 1-2 days for a basic store. Choose a theme (many free options), add your first 5-10 products with detailed descriptions and multiple photos. Set up payment gateways (like Shopify Payments). Connect a custom domain. Install key apps like a review app or an email marketing app (like Klaviyo or Mailchimp). You'll then need to plan your first traffic-driving strategy (e.g., social media promotion, paid ads).

RECOMMENDED TOOLS

Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Related Guides